Thanksgiving Bakery Pre-Orders: Pickup Boxes, Labels and How Many to Order
Updated · Vorex Packaging
Plan Thanksgiving pre-order packaging from your menu: group items into three or four box sizes (a pie box, a deeper bakery box for cakes, a cookie or cupcake box, a bag for rolls), put a label with the customer's name and pickup slot on every box, and count box quantities from your order cap plus a margin. Our Thanksgiving bakery box is 8 x 8 x 5 in with a window lid and our pie box 10 x 10 x 2.5 in, both 18pt SBS, in 250 and 500 packs or as a single test box.
The short answer
A bakery that takes Thanksgiving pre-orders needs three packaging decisions made before the order form opens: which boxes the menu items go in, how each order is labelled so the right box goes to the right customer at pickup, and how many of each box to order so you do not run out in the last week. For most bakeries that means a Thanksgiving bakery box for cakes and mixed desserts (our listed one is 8 x 8 x 5 in with a lock-corner window lid in 18pt SBS paperboard), a pie box for pies (10 x 10 x 2.5 in, window lid), and a simple roll label or sticker with the customer's name and pickup time. The bakery box is also listed as a 250 pack, a 500 pack and a single printed box you can test first.
Plan packaging from the pre-order menu
Start with the menu, not the box catalogue. Write down every item you will take orders for and the container it leaves the shop in. A typical Thanksgiving menu has a short list of shapes: round pies, layer or bundt cakes, dinner rolls, cookies or bars, and small add-ons. Group the items by shape and you will usually find that three or four box sizes cover the whole menu.
- Pies: one pie box size for your standard pan, measured on a baked pie. Our guide to pie box sizes shows how to measure across the crimp and at the tallest point.
- Cakes and mixed dessert orders: a deeper bakery box. The 8 x 8 x 5 in box gives height for a layer cake or a stacked dessert order; taller cakes need a box made to size.
- Cookies, bars and brownies: a shallow cookie box keeps them flat and stops sliding.
- Cupcakes: a cupcake box with a cavity insert, so the frosting does not touch the lid.
- Rolls and bread: a printed bakery bag is often enough.
Fewer sizes make pre-order day easier: staff grab the right box without thinking, and you order larger runs of a few items instead of small runs of many.
Pickup boxes that survive the car ride
Thanksgiving pickup orders travel in cars, often on a seat or in a trunk with other groceries. The box has to keep its shape when it is stacked and carried.
- Lock-corner or window lid boxes fold up quickly and hold their corners when stacked two or three high. The window lets the customer and your counter staff check the order without opening the lid.
- Board thickness: our listed bakery and pie boxes are 18pt SBS paperboard, a common choice for food boxes that are carried by hand. Very heavy orders (several pies in one carrier) need a sturdier box; ask a specialist.
- Size the box to the product. A cake with room to slide hits the walls on every turn. A little clearance on each side is enough; a lot is a problem.
- Stacking: if customers pick up several items, tell staff which box goes at the bottom (the heaviest, flattest one) and keep window lids facing up.
For more on keeping pies steady on pickup day, liners and travel, see how to package pies for Thanksgiving.
Labels that keep pre-orders straight
The most common pickup-day problem is not a crushed pie: it is a pumpkin pie given to the customer who ordered pecan. A label on every box fixes that, and it does not need to be printed on the box itself.
- Order label: customer name, order number, pickup day and time slot, and the item. Print these on plain labels in the shop, or order blank-area 3 x 3 in roll labels with your logo printed and a white space to write on.
- Flavour sticker: one box size can hold every pie flavour if a small sticker on the lid names the flavour. This is cheaper than a printed box for each flavour.
- Ingredient and allergen information: if your bakery sells packaged food, follow the labelling rules that apply to you. They differ by state, province and type of business (retail bakery, cottage food, wholesale), so check with your local health department or cottage food office rather than relying on a box supplier.
- Thank-you card: a printed thank-you card in the bag is a simple way to ask for a review or a Christmas pre-order.
How many boxes to order
Count from your pre-order numbers, not from a guess. A simple method:
- Look at last year's Thanksgiving orders by item, if you have them, or set a cap on how many of each item you will take.
- Add walk-in sales for the days before Thanksgiving.
- Add a margin for damaged boxes, re-boxing and staff mistakes.
- Round up to the nearest run size. Our Thanksgiving bakery and pie boxes are listed in 250 and 500 packs; other quantities are quoted.
If you are not sure a size works, order a single printed pie box or a single bakery box first and test it with your actual pie or cake before ordering the run.
Timing: when to order
US Thanksgiving is Thursday 26 November 2026, and most bakeries close pre-orders several days before it. Work backwards: decide the menu, then order the packaging early enough to receive it, fold a few, and test them with real product before the first pickup day. Proofs need your approval before printing, so leave time for one round of changes. We offer fast production once you approve your proof and fast delivery, but we do not promise arrival before a holiday: order early, and ask about rush if your date is tight.
Branding without slowing the line
- Print the logo, not the date. A box printed with your logo and a fall design works for Thanksgiving and the rest of the season; a box printed "Thanksgiving 2026" is waste on 27 November.
- Use the window. A window lid shows the product, so the print can stay simple: logo, website and social handle.
- Keep one look across sizes. The same colours on the pie box, bakery box and bag make a pickup order look like one set.
- Plan for Christmas too. A design without a holiday date carries into December orders; see Christmas packaging ideas.
Checklist before pre-orders open
- Menu grouped into three or four box sizes, each measured on real product.
- Box run quantities counted from caps or last year's numbers, plus a margin.
- Order labels or blank-area roll labels ready for every pickup slot.
- Flavour stickers for pies sharing one box size.
- A test box folded and tried with each item.
- Staff told which box goes with which item and how to stack them.
Sizes for cakes, pastries and cookies are in bakery box sizes. Browse the full bakery packaging range or the Thanksgiving packaging collection, or send your menu and quantities for a quote.
Box sizes in this guide
Each size has its own page with the box styles and products at that size, a dieline and a quote form with the size filled in.









