Pie Box Sizes: What Box Fits a 9-Inch and a 10-Inch Pie
Updated · Vorex Packaging
Size a pie box from the baked pie, not the number on the pan: measure across the widest point including the crimp and from the bottom of the tin to the tallest point, then add a little room on every side and above. Our listed pie box is 10 x 10 x 2.5 in inside (about 25.4 x 25.4 x 6.4 cm), which suits most standard 9-inch pies that measure under about 9.75 in across and 2.25 in tall. Ten-inch, deep-dish and tall meringue pies need a box made to their measurements.
The short answer
Size a pie box from the pie, not from the number on the pan. Measure your baked pie across its widest point, crimped rim included, and from the bottom of the tin to the highest point of the filling, then choose a box a little larger on every side. Our listed custom pie box is 10 x 10 x 2.5 in inside (about 25.4 x 25.4 x 6.4 cm), a window-lid box in 18pt SBS paperboard printed full colour. It suits pies that measure a little under 10 in across the rim and stay under about 2.25 in tall. For Thanksgiving it is also listed as a 250 pack, a 500 pack and a single printed box so you can test one pie before the full run. Wider or taller pies get a box made to your measurements.
Why "9-inch" and "10-inch" are not box sizes
The size printed on a pie plate or foil tin is a name, not a measurement you can build a box around. Two plates both sold as 9-inch can differ by the width of the rim, the slope of the sides and the depth, and once you add a fluted or crimped crust edge, the baked pie is wider than the plate's label suggests. A glass deep-dish plate, a disposable foil tin and a ceramic plate with a wide decorative rim all sit differently in a box.
That is why "what size pie box for a 9 inch pie" has no single answer that works for every bakery. The answer depends on the pans you actually bake in. Measure one finished pie from each pan you use and keep those numbers: they are the only ones your box supplier needs.
How to measure a pie for a box
- Bake first. Measure a finished pie, not the empty pan. Crusts puff, crimps spread and toppings rise.
- Width: measure across the widest point, including the crimped edge and any rim of the pan that sticks out past it. Take two measurements at right angles and use the larger one.
- Height: stand a ruler next to the pie on a flat counter and read the tallest point: the top of a lattice, the peak of a meringue, a crumble or a whipped topping.
- Add clearance. Leave room on every side so the tin lifts out without the crimp catching on the box wall. About a quarter of an inch per side is a practical starting point; a test box tells you whether your crust needs more.
- Add headroom. The window lid should not touch the filling. Soft tops (meringue, cream, whipped topping) need more space than a flat pumpkin or custard pie.
Write the numbers as inside length x width x height. If you sell several pie sizes, list each one separately in your quote request.
Will a 9-inch pie fit a 10 x 10 box?
Usually there is room for it, but check with your own pie. With our listed box, the space is 10 in by 10 in on the base and 2.5 in high. If your 9-inch pie measures less than about 9.75 in across the rim, it leaves the quarter-inch per side suggested above. If it is a standard-depth fruit, pumpkin or pecan pie that stays under about 2.25 in tall, the lid clears it too. A tall meringue or a mile-high apple pie is the usual reason a 9-inch pie needs a taller box rather than a wider one.
Will a 10-inch pie fit?
Often not. A pie sold as 10-inch can measure 10 in or more across its crimped edge, which leaves no room in a 10 x 10 in base: the crust drags on the walls when it goes in and comes out. For 10-inch pies, ask for a box a size up made to your measurement, with the height set for your deepest pie. The same pie box style, print and window are made at that size; you only send the new dimensions.
Sizes at a glance
| What you sell | Starting point | Check before ordering |
|---|---|---|
| Standard 9-inch fruit, pumpkin or pecan pie | Our listed 10 x 10 x 2.5 in pie box | Rim width under about 9.75 in, height under about 2.25 in |
| 9-inch pie with meringue or tall topping | Same base, taller box made to size | Measure the peak of the topping |
| Deep-dish pie | Box made to your measured width and height | Deep-dish pans are usually wider at the rim too |
| 10-inch pie | One size up from 10 x 10 in, made to size | Measure across the crimp |
| Pie with sides, rolls or cookies | Thanksgiving bakery box, deeper build | Everything in the order, not just the pie |
| Slices and hand pies | Small bakery boxes | A whole-pie box lets a slice tip over |
Metric conversions: 10 in = 25.4 cm, 9.75 in = about 24.8 cm, 2.5 in = about 6.4 cm.
Window lid, base and board
Pie boxes are shallow and square because they fold flat, stack evenly in a car and leave corners for lifting the tin. A die-cut window on the lid shows the crust at pickup, which helps when the counter is full of near-identical boxes. Our listed box is 18pt SBS paperboard; for buttery crusts, ask about a grease-resistant coating or a liner under the tin. If you sell pies in pairs or with sides, a box with a carry handle (handle boxes) or a window box in a larger size may suit better than two pie boxes.
Thanksgiving: sizing before the rush
U.S. Thanksgiving falls on Thursday, 26 November 2026, and most pie shops take pre-orders for it. The weeks before are when box sizes go wrong: a new pan arrives, a special flavour comes out taller, or a bakery adds a 10-inch option. A few habits help:
- Measure every pie on your Thanksgiving menu, including specials, before you order boxes.
- Order one single printed box first and test it with each pie, then order the run.
- Order early and ask about rush if your date is tight; we do not promise arrival before a holiday.
- Use one box size for several flavours and a flavour sticker on the lid, instead of a printed box for every pie.
What to send for a quote
- Each pie's measured width (across the crimp) and height, and how many of each size.
- Window or solid lid, and white or kraft board.
- Your artwork or logo; a specialist sends a proof before anything is printed.
- Any extras: inserts that hold the tin, liners, flavour stickers.
Browse the rest of the bakery packaging range or the full Thanksgiving packaging collection.
Box sizes in this guide
Each size has its own page with the box styles and products at that size, a dieline and a quote form with the size filled in.









